In a distinguished 40-year career in Rhode Island, Judge Caprio was celebrated for prioritizing the personal circumstances of those he judged, often invoking laughter and warmth in his courtroom. His show, "Caught in Providence," garnered billions of views and made him a social media sensation. Videos featured him sharing light-hearted moments, like inviting children to join him and creating a soft toy bearing his likeness, bringing joy to many.

His son, David Caprio, expressed gratitude for the support from fans and urged others to honor his father's memory by spreading kindness. The statement on Instagram commemorating Judge Caprio emphasized his numerous acts of kindness and the influence he had on those around him, with a phrase that resonated: “His warmth, humour, and kindness left an indelible mark on all who knew him.”

Throughout its airing, "Caught in Providence" received multiple nominations for Daytime Emmys, solidifying Judge Caprio's impact in the television world. The show’s producers, Debmar-Mercury, acknowledged Judge Caprio's unique ability to blend compassion with common sense, expressing deep sorrow at his passing.

After being diagnosed in 2023, Judge Caprio remained hopeful and publicly thanked his followers for their encouragement even as he faced health challenges. He leaves behind his wife, Joyce Caprio, married for nearly 60 years, along with five children, seven grandchildren, and two great-grandchildren.